This section is used to identify the many questions, inconsistencies, disagreements and mysteries that we have encountered in our research of the Theriault genealogy. These are the issues that we tend to concentrate on in our research. Our hope is that you may have some information, or a different point of view that can resolve these mysteries...



1. The Case of the Two Family Crests...  We have encountered two very different crests that have been identified as the Theriault family crests.  The two are shown below. (Click on each crest for a larger, higher resolution graphic of each that you can download.)  Which of the two (if any) is the authentic Theriault family crest?  Or, are both of these crests, legitimate crests of the Theriault family? 
 


2. Did Joseph Marry Josette or Agnes? In the fifth generation of Father Louis Cyr's genealogy of the Joseph Theriault Great-Branch, the fifth generation grandson Joseph (Claude, Germain, Claude, Jehan) is shown as having married Josette Girouard in Riviere aux Canards in 1758. Other records however (e.g., Linda Dube's THERIAULT GENEALOGY) show Joseph married to M. Agnes Cormier in 1746. Both versions show Joseph having a son, Charles who married Anne Blondeau in Riviere Ouelle on 21 October 1793. However, in the "M. Agnes Cormier" version, the couple's last two children (M. Genevieve and Charlotte) are shown as having been born five years or more after Joseph died. So there's obviously at least this problem with the "M.Agnes Cormier" version. Which version is correct?

Mr. Stephen White was very timely in publishing his long-awaited "DICTIONNAIRE GÉNÉALOGIQUE DES FAMILLES ACADIENNES" a few weeks ago.  I just received my two volume copy which covers the years around 1630 to 1720. On page 1500 of Volume II, he notes that according to Mr. A. Godbout, noted Acadian genealogist and researcher, Joseph, son of Claude Theriot and Anne Richard was born around 1719 and married around 1746 to Agnes CORMIER. This affirms Linda Dube's records in "THERIAULT GENEALOGY". However, it does not resolve the discrepancy with the birthdates for the last two children. Stephen White affirms Joseph's deceased date as 6/7 November 1765 in Ste-Anne de la Pocatiere, PQ.

We must remember that the time period surrounding these dates and the Great Eviction were tumultuous times for most Acadian families. Many records were lost or destroyed.



3. SOLVED:  Did Germain and Anne Marry Three Times?  There are three possible marriage dates for Anne Richard and Germain Terriault in the Third Generation of the Jehan Terriault family:
  • Linda Dube's 'Theriault Genealogy' shows 25 Jun 1685 on page 216,
  • Linda Dube's 'Theriault Genealogy' shows 10 May 1685 on page 218,
  • and Father Louis J Cyr shows 1686 in his 'Theodule Theriault' genealogy.
  • Which is the correct date? Again, I consulted with Mr. Stephen White in his "DICTIONNAIRE GÉNÉALOGIQUE DES FAMILLES ACADIENNES", and he reports that the 1686 Census of Acadia shows Germain and Anne as married. The exact date is apparently not known at least according to Mr. White's research. This seems to bring into question, Linda Dube's dates... both of them.


    4. From Northern Maine, the Three Theriault Brothers... We've received an inquiry from Dave Thireault (no, this is not a spelling error, just another variation of our last name) of Minnesota. His grandfather Denis Theriault was born in 1889 in Huot, Minnesota, a small french community near Red Lake Falls, in northwestern Minnesota. His great-grandfather, also named Denis and his two brothers, Isaac and Zephier came from Maine via Canada into northern Minnesota in the early 1890's. The three brothers followed the logging industry. Great-grandfather Denis and his brother Zephier were married to sisters from the Charles Guimont family. Denis married Matilda Guimont. Matilda had a brother George and a sister Ida. The three Theriault brothers and their wives moved into northern Minnesota in the early 1890's when the area was open for homesteading. Dave explains that his grandmother switched the 'i' and 'e' around in their last name to keep their mail from getting mixed up with another family of Theriault's closeby. Before that, the name had the more common spelling. Dave's grandfather Denis married Nina Costello whose father was Irish and mother was Swedish. The Costello's homesteaded in Saint Anthony, Minnesota, a part of present-day Minneapolis.

    For those of you who have access to source data of the northern Maine and New Brunswick parishes, please keep Denis Theriault (born in 1889) and his wife Nina Costello in mind; as well as Denis' father, Denis Theriault and his wife Matilda Guimont. We are looking for the connection back into the Theriault family for this lumberjack family.



    5. Where did Fabien Come From?  We've received another inquiry regarding Fabien Theriault who married Tharzile Bertin. Linda Dubé lists them in her book "THERIAULT GENEALOGY". Fabien was born on 3 Apr 1828 in New Brunswick and died on 2 Jan 1916 and that Tharzile died in Palmer Road, PEI (no date). One of their children is listed, Bruno, a son who in turn married Virginie Jeanne Clement on 15 April 1888 in Palmer Road, PEI. Linda shows Bruno born in Palmer Road and shows him as having died also in 1916. Sounds like it might have been a father/son accident. Bruno's twelve children are listed as are their descendants from that generation.

    We are told by one of our website visitors "... that Fabien and Tharzile were listed in the RC census of Palmer Road in 1890 as age 62 (Fabien) and 56 (Tharsille Bertin).  They had several children, some not in the household at that time.  Julia Theriault, one of their daughters is my great grandmother, who married Agno Duguay son of Francis Xavier/Dauphine Bernard (Tignish,PEI).  Regarding Fabien Theriault, the PEI gov had records of death and burial for Summerside, PEI, 1916."

    The mystery is where did Fabien come from? Monsieur Fidèle Theriault offers no hint that Fabien's origins might have been from the Caraquet area. Please let us know if you have any information on this couple. It will make at least two people very happy: our visitor and myself...

    21 Jan 2001:  We received a note from Mr. Gerald Peskett who says:
    "In regards to question 5 in your unsolved mysteries, regarding Fabien and Tharsile Bertin.  According to the "Répertoire Alphabétique Des Mariages Des Canadiens-Francais de 1760 à 1935" by Claude Drouin:

    As listed:
    theriau     fabien
    bretain     tharsile         a bathurst n.b
                                       -de new bandon
    ----                              24 juil. 1854

    As you will notice the spelling differs for Tharsile's last name but it would appear to be the couple in question, and it seems to suggest that Fabien was from New Bandon, New Brunswick.
    Another listing for a Fabien is a such:
    therriau         fabien
    porrier          susanne         a bathurst n.b.
                                            -de new bandon
    ----                                  4 nov. 1851

    Possibly these entries are for the same individual.  Unfortunately no parents names are listed on these two entries but it may give you a location to check into.

    26 Dec 2003:  In a message from M. Fidèle Thériault way back on 17 July 2002, we receive the resolution to this mystery. Monsieur Thériault says: "Fabien Theriault who married to Tharsile Bertin is no longer a mystery for me.  He was a native of Grande-Anse (N.-B.) and the son of Paul Thériault and Marie Fournier.  He moved to PEI (Palmer Road) about 1877.  Gerald Peskett has the correct date for his marriage.  The Fabien Thériault who married Suzanne Poirier in 1851 is from another branch."  My apologies to Monsieur Thériault and to our visitors for this oversight in posting his response in a timely manner.



    6. The Twin Brothers from Caribou, Maine... Lynda Theriault (who lives in Maine) is asking whether we have any information on her Theriault lineage. Her grandfather's/"pépére's"  name was Hector who had a twin brother named Oscar. The twin brothers' father was Nomi Theriault who was married to Elise Blis?. They lived in the Caribou, Maine area. She has no birth, marriage or deceased dates. Her father is Sheldon Theriault living in Maine.


     
     

    Send me your solution at this address: