<BGSOUND src="music/midi/gaspe.mid">FAMILY'S UNSOLVED MYSTERIES
Background midi music: "The Gaspé Reel / The Mouth of the Tobique / Mother's Reel" Sequenced by Barry Taylor, Victoria, BC, Canada
This section is used to identify the many questions, inconsistencies, disagreements and mysteries that I have encountered in my research of the Theriault genealogy. These are the issues that I tend to concentrate on in my research. My hope is that you have some information that can resolve one or more of these mysteries.



Mystery #1. Not much is known about four of Joseph and Théogénie's children:  Charles, Josephine,  Denis, and Levite. What do we know about whether they married, who did they marry, how many children did they have? What did they do for a living? Where did they live? did some of them die early?
 
In this picture of the Joseph and Théogénie family which was taken in 1905, none of the four missing children are shown. Also not shown are Joachim, the second oldest son who was 19 at the time of this photo, and Almida who would not be born for another three years. According to the caption below a copy of this photo in Linda Dubé's "THERIAULT GENEALOGY", the young children standing in front are, left to right: Antoine (5 years), Christine (3 years), Delia (2 years) and Flavie (7 years) standing at the far right. The adults standing behind are, left to right: Regis (20 years), Edith (17 years), Joseph (47 years), Delphine (15 years) and Théogénie (41 years). According to Linda Dubé's caption, the elder lady sitting in the center is Mrs. David Rousseau.
With the professional help of Monsieur Fernand Lévesque of New Brunswick, a genealogist and himself a descendant of the Thériault family through his mother, we were able to solve the mystery associated with four children listed in Linda Dubé's THERIAULT GENEALOGY. (See the 20 January SPECIAL NOTE in Letters...)

By reviewing the Census records of 1891 and 1901 and the parochial registers of St-Jacques, St-Hilaire, St-Basile and of Edmundston, M. Lévesque determined the birth dates and dates deceased for three of the children thus confirming their existence. Mr. Lévesque did confirm the accidental death by drowning of Dénis on 17 December, 1901 at the age of 10. In discussions with the family in New Brunswick, there is a story that has been passed down that Dénis died by drowning in the Iroquois River in St-Jacques. We believe that Joseph and Théogénie lived in the Moulin Morneault area of St-Jacques. The area is very picturesque with many hills. One of the hills was popular for sledding although unfortunately its slopes plunged steeply into the Iroquois River. On Tuesday, the 17 December 1901 probably after school, in the week before Christmas, young Dénis was sledding on that hill but failed to stop at the edge of the river at a time when the river was not quite frozen. He broke through the ice and was not able to surface. His body was recovered in May of 1902, about a month  after his baby sister, Christine was born.

According to Georgette Theriault Cyr, Joachim's elder son, Denis was named after him. In a telephone conversation with Armand Leclerc (Christine, Joseph), Armand said that his mother spoke of two older brothers who died in their infancy. As to the daughter named 'Josephine' as listed in Linda Dubé's THERIAULT GENEALOGY, no records were found her. 

We are grateful to Monsieur Lévesque for his generous assistance.

Here is a family timeline which presents the  correct sequence of births, marriages and deaths according to the Canadian Cenuses of 1891, 1901 and the parochial registers of St-Jacques, St-Hilaire, St-Basile and of Edmundston:
 
 

Joseph & Théogénie Family Time-Line
Dec 1858
   Joseph is born in St-Jacques
Mar 1864 Théogénie is born in Rimouski, PQ
Feb 1882 Joseph marries Théogénie Ouellet in St-Jaques
Mar 1885 Régis is born in St-Jacques
Jul 1886 Joachim is born in St-Jacques
May 1888 Edith is born in St-Jacques
Jun 1890 Delphine is born in St-Jacques
Aug 1891 Dénis is born in St-Jacques
May 1894 Charles is born in St-Jacques (no date deceased found)
Aug 1895 Lévite is born in St-Jacques
Aug 1897 Lévite dies (cause unknown)
Sep 1898 Flavie is born in St-Jacques
Jan 1900 Antoine is born in St-Jacques
Dec 1901 Dénis dies by drowning in St-Jacques
Mar 1902 Christine is born in St-Jacques
Oct 1903 Delia is born in St-Jacques
May 1906 Edith marries Charles Roussel in St-Jacques
Jul 1908 Almida is born in St-Hilaire
Aug 1909 Joachim marries Annie Madore in Ste-Luce
Apr 1910 Régis marries Égline Lysotte in St-Hilaire
Jul 1915 Joseph dies in St-Hilaire (cause unknown)
Jul 1920 Delphine,Flavie marry Liquori Bouchard,Claude Daigle respectively, in a double ring ceremony in St-Hilaire
 ?  1921 Christine marries Lorenzo LeClerc in Drummond, NB
Oct 1926 Delia marries Frank Martin in Baker-Brook
Jun 1929 Antoine marries Evangeline 'Eva' Lévesque in Nashua
Sep 1947 Joachim dies (brain aneurism) in Baker-Brook
?  1947 Almida dies (cause unknown) in St-Basile
Feb 1952 Flavie dies (cause unknown) in Edmundston
Jul 1952 Théogénie dies (cause unknown) in St-Basile
Dec 1959 Régis dies (cause unknown) in Nashua
Dec 1962 Édith dies (cause unknown) in St-Basile
Oct 1971 Delphine dies (cause unknown) in Edmundston ?
Dec 1974 Antoine dies (cause unknown) in Nashua
Dec 1982 Christine dies (cause unknown) in Berlin
May 1991 Delia dies (cause unknown) in St-Basile
         

One side question about this important photo above: this was obviously a special occasion or at least the family prepared for the photo since all are well-dressed. It is curious that Joachim was not in the photo. He was 19 years old when this photo was taken and presumably was still living at home working with his father. He is the only one missing. Almida (Sister Ste-Jeanne D'arc) was not born yet.

Mystery #2.  Other questions about this photo:

The photo above was taken around the time that Joseph and Théogénie moved their family to St-Hilaire. Is this the family house of Joseph and Théogenie? Was it in St-Jacques, Moulin Morneault or St-Hilaire? Are there other photos which show this house? Does that house still exist today? Judging by the orientation of the photo, the house was located on a high slope with the front yard sloping down away from the house toward the road in front. I don't believe that the village of St-Jacques nor of St-Hilaire have any sloping areas like this but the Moulin Morneault settlement certainly has. We must remember also that by now, the house may have been remodeled or possibly even razed and replaced by a new one.

Mystery #3.  Who was Mrs. David Rousseau shown in the photo above? What was her proper and maiden name?
 

We also learned from Monsieur Lévesque's research that Joachim's birth certificate lists Mr. David Rousseau as his Godfather. Therefore, the elder lady in the photo Mrs. David Rousseau was his wife. Caroline Plourde was listed on the birth certificate as the Godmother. It is not known whether Caroline Plourde was the wife of David Rousseau.


Mystery #4.  Speaking of houses, here's another photo which raises some questions. The location of the house is not known although the setting is not a country setting... it is a town or city setting. Judging by Théogénie's appearance and age (in her late 60's) and the horse-drawn 'carriole' in front, the period of this photo is the 1930's. At this time, Edith, Delphine, Flavie and Delia were married. Antoine and Christine were also married and raising their families in Nashua and in Berlin, respectively.

A close look at the photo (click on it to zoom) shows that there probably is a store in the house (at least there is a sign advertising 'smoking' tobacco... MASON?), Théogénie is standing in the entryway. I believe that the young lady in front, looking down is probably Flavie, and I also believe that the other young lady to the right of Théogénie could be Edith or Delphine but since she is not wearing glasses, then it must be Delphine. Later photos of Delphine compare favorably with this one. Also, it looks like Théogénie is at home and since I don't believe she ever stayed with Edith, I think we can eliminate the Roussel house as a possibility. So this is either the Bouchard house (Delphine), the Daigle house (Flavie) or the Martin house (Delia). Since it is Delphine who looks at home in her apron, I believe that this is the Bouchard house with Mon Oncle Liquori at the door waving his hat. And, the young lady who is furthest left is either Delia or Almida before she took her vows in 1935. I can't even begin to identify the other men although they look very much like they're at home here... But in order to fully identify this photo, we need to confirm first whose house this is and where it was located.  Is it Delphine's house? ...Flavie's house? ...Delia's house? You may download this photo (right click on the photo and select SAVE AS, or SAVE TARGET AS), print it enlarged to the size of an 8-1/2 x 11 sheet of paper to get the detail.



Mystery #5.  In the fifth generation of Father Louis Cyr's genealogy of the Joseph Theriault Great-Branch, Joseph (who is one of the sons of Claude Terriot and Marguerite Cormier) is shown as having married Josette Girouard in Riviere aux Canards in 1758. Other records however (e.g., Linda Dube's THERIAULT GENEALOGY) show Joseph married to M. Agnes Cormier in 1746. Both versions show Joseph having a son, Charles who married Anne Blondeau in Riviere Ouelle on 21 October 1793. However, in the "M. Agnes Cormier" version, the couple's last child is born in 1770, five years after Joseph died. So there's obviously at least this problem with the "M.Agnes Cormier" version. Which version is correct?
 
This is a little complicated because several researchers including Father Louis Cyr, Linda Dubé, Adrien Bergeron and Stephen A. White have 'weighed in' on Joseph, son of Claude Terriot and Marguerite Cormier . 
  1. First as to who he married. All, except Father Cyr agree that Joseph married Marie Agnès Cormier around 1746 in the Rivière aux Canards area of Grand-Pré, Acadia. So, we will conclude that Father Cyr was just having a bad day when he arrived at his conclusion that Joseph married Josette Girouard in Rivière-aux-Canards in 1758.

  2.  
  3. Second, as to Joseph's birthdate. Here, White indicates agreement with A. Godbout that the birthdate is around 1719. Bergeron claims 1723 and Linda lists 1726 as the correct birthdate.  Only Linda shows a birthplace of Ste-Anne-de-la-Pocatière. Joseph's marriage to Marie Agnès Cormier in Rivière aux Canards makes it unlikely that he was born in Ste-Anne-de-la-Pocatière. Why should someone born on the St-Lawrence travel some 500 miles to Acadia for his bride? It is more likely that Joseph was born in Grand-Pré like his brothers and sisters before and after him, as reflected in Stephen A. White's authoritative research.

  4.  
  5. Third, as to Joseph's children. Here, only Bergeron and Dubé have any information. Here's what we have:
    • Jacques Leon, born 1747. Married Françoise Fortin on 20 Feb 1776 in St-Jean Port Joli
    • Anselme, born 1748. Married Marie Romaine Thibodeau on 30 Jan 1775 in L'Islet
    • Cecile, born 1755. Married Romain Dutremble on 10 Feb 1777 in St-Jean Port Joli
    • Marie-Anne, born 1757. Married Zacharie Dufour on 8 Jan 1781 in St-Jean Port Joli
    • Charles-Marie. Married Marie-Anne Blondeau on 21 Oct 1793 in Rivière-Ouelle
    • Antoine, born 1765. Married Marie Madeleine Dionne on 6 Oct 1794 and in a second marriage, Appoline-Françoise Leclerc on 11 Oct 1796 in St-Jean Port Joli
    • Charlotte (no birthdate). Married Benoni Hudon (widower of Barbe Michaud) on 11 Apr 1796 in Kamouraska
    Linda Dubé also lists, Joseph Pierre (born about 1751 who married Genevieve Bouchard on 7 Nov 1800),  Marguerite (born about 1752 who married Germain Senechal), Marie-Genevieve (born 1 Dec 1770, who married Auguste Blais in St-Jean Port Joli) and Catherine (born on 1 Nov 1759 in Acadia, who married Michel Senechal on 4 Jul 1785 in St-Roch des A...
     
  6. Fourth, as to Joseph's deceased date. Here White gives with certainty the 6th/7th Nov 1765 as the dates deceased/buried in St-Anne-de-la-Pocatière. Linda Dubé agrees with that data. This means that Antoine was their last child and that Charles-Marie and Charlotte were born sometime before 1765. 



Mystery #6.  We do not know much about 'vieux grandpère' Joe Theriault's life other than the vital statistics in our database. We know that he and Théogénie lived in Saint Jacques where they were married. But we wonder what he did for a living. The Theriault's were known to be millwrights (builders of mills... saw mills, flour mills...) and millers, operators of mills. Was that his 'metiers' and trade? As to Théogénie, was she educated as a teacher?
 
February 2001:  In some recent conversations with Georgette Theriault Cyr, Marie-Ange Theriault and Jeannine Theriault Lévesque, we learned that Joseph operated (and may have owned) a  mill in his early years in the Moulin Morneault area of St-Jacques. We also now know that he acquired some land in Baker-Brook (actually the land straddles the St-Hilaire / Baker-Brook line) and built a water-driven mill on a brook feeding the St-John River. The mill was used to saw wood and mill flour. Joseph built the mill and moved his family to Baker-Brook/St-Hilaire sometime before 1908 when Almida was born (in St-Hilaire). Before Almida, Delia was born in 1903 in St-Jacques. 

As to Théogénie, we really do not know her education and if she was educated whether she was a teacher. We do know that one of Joseph and Théogénie's priorities was to provide an education for their daughters. We know that when Joseph was no longer able to manage the mill, he offered the mill to Joachim. But in return, he asked Joachim to make sure that his younger sisters finish their school. Joachim accepted.

Of their seven daughters, we believe that at least Delphine, Delia and Flavie had time before getting married to complete a course of education in teaching. In fact, Delphine was 25 when her father, Joseph died. So if she did go to school, her schooling was complete when her father died. Also, we know that Almida's education was in nursing as a Sister of the Hospitalières de St-Joseph. Since Edith and Christine were 18 and 19 when they married, if they did finish their schooling, they were not able to teach for very long before they started their own families. 

Of their six sons, only three survived beyond early childhood. In those difficult times, sons were expected to be earning their own living by the age of 16-17, either by working for their father, or away from home working for someone else. Unfortunately, of his remaining three sons, only the two elder sons were able to help Joseph with his mill. When Joseph's health began to fail in 1913, Antoine was 13, Joachim was 27 and married, and Regis was 28 and married. Regis and his new wife had gone to New Hampshire to earn their living, leaving only Joachim in position to help his father.


 



Mystery #7.  We have a photo shown here of Théogénie with one of her sons, Joachim (my grandfather) on what is probably the front porch of her home in Edmundston. Can anyone confirm that? The photo was taken in the 1940's long after Joseph died. Did Théogénie move after Joseph died? If so, where?
 
Theogenie Theriault and son, Joachim Theriault (at Theogenie's home in Edmundston, NB, Canada?)15 Dec 2000:  I was absolutely delighted to receive a note from Antoine Thériault (George, Joachim, Joseph), my good cousin from New Brunswick. I am very glad to see him on the Internet. Antoine explained  "...My father told me the history about the picture of Théogénie & Joachim Thériault standing on the porch of the house. This house was on Bellevue Street in Edmundston, N.B., and he told me that grand père Joachim  stopped there after coming out of the hospital." Antoine continues "I think my father told me that the house belonged to the father of his cousin Roland Daigle.  I  do not know if Théogénie lived there or if she was just visiting the Daigle family."

Antoine said that he has the same picture in his house. If we look at our Archive, we see that Roland Daigle is the son of Claude Daigle and Flavie Thériault. Flavie was the eleventh child (fifth daughter) of Joseph and Théogenie. Now, I recently discussed this photo with Ma Tante Georgette (Joachim, Joseph) a few months ago. She said that this picture was taken during Pepere's last days in 1947 when his health was beginning to fail. She explained that Grandmère Théogénie lived with Flavie until she (Flavie) died in February 1952. Grandmére then went to live with Delphine on Rue L'Nott(?) until Grandmére died in July of that same year.

So, given what Mon Oncle George told Antoine, Pepére had just come out of the hospital (which would have been the Sanitorium in St-Basile) and had stopped for a short visit with his mother before returning home in their little red house in Baker-Brook. So this was the summer of 1947. Pepére Joachim died on 30 September 1947 at the Sanitorium in St-Basile of an aneurysm of the brain which  caused a brain hemorrhage.This then may have been the last photo ever taken of Grand Pére Joachim.

Thanks for helping solve this one, Antoine!



Mystery #8.  In going through our source data for Joseph and Théogénie Theriault, we have encountered a second and third name for Théogénie. Some records list her as Théojeanne, others as Theogone. Which was her real name? Théogénie, Théojeanne, Theogone?
 
22 Feb 2000: This part of the mystery is now solved! I have received an authoritative and very informative letter from Fernand and Marie-Ange Levesque, Acadian and French-Canadian genealogists in New Brunswick, who attached copies of the Birth of Certificates and Marriage Certificates of Joseph and Théogénie. Very clearly, her name on her Baptismal Certificate was indeed Théogénie. Not Theojeanne or Theogone as seen in some records. (See the Letters & Email page) Thank you, M./Mme Levesque.
But the story does not end with this solution. With the same information that resolved one mystery, yet another mystery though more serious was raised regarding our records associated with Théogénie. Our current genealogical records show her parents as being Honoré Ouellet and Rose Caron. However, her birth certificate shows her parents as being Benoit Ouellet and Elizabeth Thériault! Here are the transcripts of the baptismal and marriage certificates that was researched by M/Mme Levesque:
Transcription de l’acte de baptême de Théogénie Ouellet : « Le vingt sept mars mil huit cent soixante quatre nous soussigné curé de cette paroisse avons baptisé Marie Théogénie Ouellet, née la veille du légitime mariage de Benoit Ouellet, cultivateur du lieu, et de Elisabeth Thériault. Parrain Paul Ouellet, marraine Xantippe Demers qui n’ont pu signer. Le père absent. Signé : G. Nadeau, ptre. » (Protonotaire de Rimouski, registres d’état civil, paroisse de Sainte-Luce, QC, microfilm M 178/42, p. 0783, Archives nationales du Québec, Québec, QC.

Transcription de l’acte de mariage de Joseph Thériault et Théogone Ouellet : Le 5 février 1882 « Après la publication de 2 bancs de mariage entre Joseph Thériault et Théogone Ouelletnous soussigné avons reçu leur consentement mutuel de mariage en présence de Dolphis Thériault et Pierre Plourde. Signé : L.C. D’Amours, ptre. » (Registres paroissiaux de Saint-Jacques, microfilm A4520 (F15720), Archives provinciales du Nouveau-Brunswick, Fredericton, NB.)

You can see how the problem with Théogénie's name began. Her own marriage certificate shows her name as Théogone. But as to the error regarding her parents, somehow, this error has been missed by more than a few researchers. Most of the data that I have seen including those of Father Louis Cyr and those reflected in Linda Dube's THERIAULT GENEALOGY, indicate that Théogénie's parents were Honore Ouellet and Rose Caron. The Ouellet and Caron genealogy continues for three generations after to the mid-1700's. So, it's back to the detective work, to research the Benoit Ouellet and Elizabeth Thériault 'connection'. An interesting question about this new development is to identify the branch of the Theriault family to which Elizabeth belonged.

18 December 2000:  Received a note from the other genealogist in my family, my dear paternal cousin Claude Thériault... the guy that I mention as one of my inspirations on our home page. Claude tells me that according to Adrien Bergeron in his book "LE GRAND ARRANGEMENT DES ACADIEN AU QUEBEC", the parents of Elizabeth Thériault were Abraham and Marie-Reine Gagnon, who were married in St-Jean Port-Joli, PQ on 25 Aug 1811. Claude adds that Benoit Ouellet and Elizabeth married in Cacouna, PQ on 1 April 1845. By identifying Elizabeth's parents, I was able to determine Elizabeth's lineage in the Theriault family from Linda Dubé's THERIAULT GENEALOGY book. It turns out that Théogénie's 2nd great-grandparents, Joseph Theriault and Marie-Agnes Cormier are also her husband, Joseph's 2nd great-grandparents. In other words, Joseph and Théogénie were 3rd cousins. Thank you Claude! I've added the details to our Archive. It will be posted as part of Revision 2001.1 later this winter. Another mystery solved!

Mystery #9.  Going further backwards in our family history, let me begin by reviewing our Great-Branch ancestors from Joseph and Théogénie, whose father was Dolphis Théophile. Although some records identify him as Adolphe, he should not be confused with his younger brother whose name was Adolphe and who was born in December of 1823. Dolphis was born in 1822 in St-Basile. He married Christine Sophie Soucy from St-Basile in 1854 and later moved to St-Jacques as one of the first settlers in St-Jacques.

Dolphis' father was Charles. We believe (although we have not yet found any records of his birth) that Charles was born in Ste-Anne de la Pocatière. We do have records that he married Marie Léocadie Gagnon in Ste-Anne de la Pocatière in 1821 and moved to St-Basile where in 1822, his first child, a son, Dolphis was born. So Charles was the first in our Great-Branch to migrate to the St-John Valley... this was 50 years after Joseph R Theriault, Jr. moved to St-Basile to form several different Great-Branches of Theriault's. (Read about the migration of the three Great-Branches (so far documented) that descended from Joseph R in the 'Migration' section of our Jehan & Perrine Theriot Family website.

Our existing records show that Charle's wife died six years after they married and was buried in St-Basile in April 1827. We do not know whether Charles remarried. Nor do we know when Charles died nor where he was buried. So, the mystery is: where did Charles die and where was he buried? Did he remarry? Can we find Léocadie's burial place in St-Basile? If so, is there a headstone? Any hints as to Charle's life after Léocadie died?
 

  Click on my address to send me your solution: joseph-theogenie@terriau.org

|Table of Contents |